Annual risk of tuberculous infection using different methods in communities with a high prevalence of TB and HIV in Zambia and South Africa

Shanaube, Kwame
Sisminidis, Charalambos
Ayles, Helen
Beyers, Nulda
Schaap, Ab
Lawrence, Katherine-Anne
Barker, Annie
Godfrey-Faussett, Peter
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Public Library of Science (PLOS)
Background: The annual risk of tuberculous infection (ARTI) is a key epidemiological indicator of the extent of transmission in a community. Several methods have been suggested to estimate the prevalence of tuberculous infection using tuberculin skin test data. This paper explores the implications of using different methods to estimate prevalence of infection and ARTI. The effect of BCG vaccination on these estimates is also investigated. Methodology/Principal Findings: Tuberculin surveys among school children in 16 communities in Zambia and 8 in South Africa (SA) were performed in 2005, as part of baseline data collection and for randomisation purposes of the ZAMSTAR study. Infection prevalence and ARTI estimates were calculated using five methods: different cut-offs with or without adjustments for sensitivity, the mirror method, and mixture analysis. A total of 49,835 children were registered for the surveys, of which 25,048 (50%) had skin tests done and 22,563 (90%) of those tested were read. Infection prevalence was higher in the combined SA than Zambian communities. The mirror method resulted in the least difference of 7.8%, whereas that estimated by the cut-off methods varied from 12.2% to 17.3%. The ARTI in the Zambian and SA communities was between 0.8% and 2.8% and 2.5% and 4.2% respectively, depending on the method used. In the SA communities, the ARTI was higher among the younger children. BCG vaccination had little effect on these estimates. Conclusions/Significance: ARTI estimates are dependent on the calculation method used. All methods agreed that there were substantial differences in infection prevalence across the communities, with higher rates in SA. Although TB notification rates have increased over the past decades, the difference in cumulative exposure between younger and older children is less dramatic and a rise in risk of infection in parallel with the estimated incidence of active tuberculosis cannot be excluded. © 2009 Shanaube et al.
The original publication is available at http:/
Medical care surveys -- Zambia, HIV Infections -- Transmission -- South Africa, Medical care surveys -- South Africa, Tuberculous infections -- Vaccination -- Zambia, Tuberculous infections -- Vaccination -- South Africa
Shanaube, K, et al. 2009. Annual Risk of Tuberculous Infection Using Different Methods in Communities with a High Prevalence of TB and HIV in Zambia and South Africa. PLoS ONE, 4(11): e7749, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007749.