A review of Aristotle’s claim regarding Pythagoreans fundamental Beliefs: all is number?

Files
cornelli_review_2016.pdf(976.71 KB)
Date
2016
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidad do Vale de Rio dos Sinos
Abstract
ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The question-statement, “All is number?”, the title of Zhmud’s famous 1989 article in Phronesis, opens a challenge to the extremely important Aristotelian testimony that “all is number” was the fundamental definition of Pythagorean philosophy. Such a challenge is anything but easy, especially when one considers that, so far, the histories of both ancient philosophy and ancient mathematics seem to have no doubts that this definition is correct. This paper aims to submit Aristotle’s claim that the Pythagoreans believed that “all is number” to critical review. Our analysis of the many ways in which Aristotle states the thesis that “all is number” will reveal, beyond merely semantic variations, a fundamental theoretical contradiction that Aristotle himself seems incapable of solving. Three different versions of the doctrine are in fact present in the Aristotelian doxography: (a) an identification of numbers with the sensible objects; (b) an identification of the principles of numbers with the principles of things that are; (c) an imitation of objects by numbers. While versions (a) and (c) seem to identify numbers with the material cause of reality, in terms (“imitation”) reminiscent of Plato, version (b), numbers as formal causes of reality, is an Aristotelian reconstruction of the Pythagorean theory. Aristotle would have been pushed to such a reconstruction by the difficulty he found in accepting the Pythagorean material notion of number, and by considering it closer to its sensitivity, strongly marked by the reception of that same theory in the Academic realm.
AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Geen opsomming beskikbaar
Description
CITATION: Cornelli, G. 2016. A review of Aristotle’s claim regarding Pythagoreans fundamental beliefs : all is number?. Filosofia Unisinos, 17(1):50-57, doi:10.4013/fsu.2016.171.06.
The original publication is available at http://revistas.unisinos.br/index.php/filosofia
Keywords
Ancient philosophy, Pythagorean proposition, Pythagorean theorem
Citation
Cornelli, G. 2016. A review of Aristotle’s claim regarding Pythagoreans fundamental beliefs : all is number?. Filosofia Unisinos, 17(1):50-57, doi:10.4013/fsu.2016.171.06
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/10019.1/102145
Collections
Research Articles (Philosophy)