The cultural semiotics of African encounters : eighteenth-century images of the Other
Date
2020-01-11
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
De Gruyter
Abstract
This a contribution to the cultural semiotics of African cultural encounters seen through the eyes of Swedish naturalists at the end of the eighteenth century. European travellers faced severe problems in understanding the alien African cultures they encountered; they even had difficulty understanding the other culture as a culture. They were not just other cultures that they could relate to, but often something completely different, belonging to the natural history of the human species. The Khoikhoi and other groups were believed by Europeans to be, from their perspective, the most distant culture. The Linnaean disciple Anders Sparrman and others, however, tried to transcend this cultural gap, and used their cognitive resources, such as empathy and intersubjectivity, in order to understand the alien culture they encountered.
The aim of this paper is to unearth the cultural semiosis of African encounters and the intersubjective challenges that human interactions provoke. These encounters not only changed the view the travellers had of the Other, but also changed themselves and their self-perception. The encounter between the Ego and the Other is, however, not static, something predestined by the differences in their cultures, but dynamic, changing according to individual encounters and the actual intersubjective interplay that transform and change the perception of the Other. There are in particular four meaning-making processes and challenges within cultural encounters that are in focus: recognizing cultural complexity; invoking intersubjectivity; determining similarities and dissimilarities; and identifying the Other as a mirror of oneself.
The triad of cultures – Ego, Alter, and Alius – can be understood as gradual and changing aspects depending on the actual situation of the encounter and the personal perspectives, interpretations, and behaviour of the thinking subjects involved. Using concrete examples from Southern and Western Africa in the 1770s and 1780s, this study aims to explore this dynamic semiosis. One of the conclusions is that the relation between the Ego and the Alter/Alius is not something only predetermined by the cultures involved and their ideologies, but also depends on the individual thinking subjects and how they use their specific cognitive and semiotic resources, not least their intersubjective abilities, within specific temporal and spatial contexts.
Description
CITATION: Duner, D. 2020. The cultural semiotics of African encounters : Eighteenth-Century images of the Other. Semiotica, 232:103–146, doi:10.1515/sem-2019-0030.
The original publication is available at https://www.degruyter.com
The original publication is available at https://www.degruyter.com
Keywords
Culture, Cultural semiotics, Cognitive history, African cultures -- 18th century, Perception of African culture, Human evolution -- Psychological aspects, Recognition of commonalities
Citation
Duner, D. 2020. The cultural semiotics of African encounters : Eighteenth-Century images of the Other. Semiotica, 232:103–146, doi:10.1515/sem-2019-0030.